You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?



9/08/2010 9:52 pm  #1


Exclusionary Practices

How about starting a Music Thread II for people who want to discuss songs 40 and 50 years old and a Music Thread III for people who want to discuss songs 60 years old?

I realize I'll have to reply to my own posts, unless Stan's more of a music lover than I've detected.  But it would be a very kind gesture.

The first four songs that I learned the lyrics for were 1.  The Marine's Hymn; 2.  Don't Fence Me In; 3.  Froggy Went a Courtin'; and 4.  Ghost Riders in the Sky.

Check out the dates on those mothers.

9/08/2010 10:40 pm  #2


Re: Exclusionary Practices

My mom introduced me to all kinds of all songs.  I thought it was normal for 10 year old boys to be able to sing "You Must Have Been a Beautiful Baby", and to say, "Wowie-kapowie"!

9/10/2010 5:49 am  #3


Re: Exclusionary Practices

I can't discuss the song with much merit but I can tell you that the episode of Tom & Jerry with Jerry's uncle singing Froggy Went a Courtin' and plucking whiskers out of Tom's face for new guitar strings was a cinematic masterpiece.

9/10/2010 10:16 am  #4


Re: Exclusionary Practices

KC_Card_Guy wrote:

I can't discuss the song with much merit but I can tell you that the episode of Tom & Jerry with Jerry's uncle singing Froggy Went a Courtin' and plucking whiskers out of Tom's face for new guitar strings was a cinematic masterpiece.

Since we don't have a rec button, can I just give a post 5 smiley faces

(grin) (grin) (grin) (grin) (grin)

9/10/2010 10:46 am  #5


Re: Exclusionary Practices

forsberg_us wrote:

KC_Card_Guy wrote:

I can't discuss the song with much merit but I can tell you that the episode of Tom & Jerry with Jerry's uncle singing Froggy Went a Courtin' and plucking whiskers out of Tom's face for new guitar strings was a cinematic masterpiece. (grin) (grin) (grin) (grin) (grin)

Since we don't have a rec button, can I just give a post 5 smiley faces

(grin) (grin) (grin) (grin) (grin)

(grin) (grin) (grin) (grin) (grin)

9/10/2010 10:48 am  #6


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Max wrote:

My mom introduced me to all kinds of all songs.  I thought it was normal for 10 year old boys to be able to sing "You Must Have Been a Beautiful Baby", and to say, "Wowie-kapowie"!

M and M, I too have certain anachronistic leanings I'd love to indulge with you.  Al Bowlly, anyone?

9/16/2010 12:16 am  #7


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Here's one for you, Mags.  This recording pushes fifty years old, but it's of a song that is much older.  Peter, Paul, and Mary weren't exactly The Weavers, and this ain't even PPM, but it's the only YouTube version I could find of one of my favorite songs, anywhere by anybody:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=duD690Dj3J8

9/16/2010 12:20 am  #8


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Here's another.  It might be a bit like Elvis in Las Vegas . . . no, it's not that bad.  It's a bit of history:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OLvk-qsKonQ

9/16/2010 12:31 am  #9


Re: Exclusionary Practices

and a third . . . I'm laughing and crying as I watch this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8c3Tjk4Ck0c&feature=related

9/16/2010 11:16 am  #10


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Max wrote:

Here's another.  It might be a bit like Elvis in Las Vegas . . . no, it's not that bad.  It's a bit of history:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OLvk-qsKonQ

Not bad at all.  Thank you, Max.  About 25 years ago, I was bemoaning how I'd chosen to waste my life on "legal education," and one of my colleagues asked me who I would most want to be like if I could be any one that ever lived.  I told her, and meant it, "Pete Seeger" and perhaps still would.  Of course, being an ignorant person, she had never heard of him.  Several years ago, I got to meet him and had a rather lengthy conversation with him at the dedication of the Civil Rights museum here in Memphis.  I learned that Lee Hayes, the guy who does the initial monologue and is wheelchair bound, is the son of a Methodist minister from Arkansas.  I didn't ask what part.

Good Night, Irene has never been one of my favorites in the repertoire of the Weavers and wasn't when it and the following were popular.  I loved this one in the early 50's and still consider it about my favorite of theirs:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aSGkvyF0jkM

I think when I was 8 or 9 I preferred the Guy Mitchell version.

Last edited by Mags (9/16/2010 11:19 am)

     Thread Starter

9/16/2010 11:18 am  #11


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Max wrote:

and a third . . . I'm laughing and crying as I watch this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8c3Tjk4Ck0c&feature=related

I always preferred the Kingston Trio with Dave Guard instead of his replacement, John Stewart.  I do like a lot of songs written by the latter before he started taking himself too seriously.

     Thread Starter

9/16/2010 11:33 am  #12


Re: Exclusionary Practices

It's hard for me to pick a favorite Weavers song, but one of 'em would be the one below.  I couldn't find a version on YouTube by Th Weavers, but I found this version by Odetta:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V26i_cHlpgA&feature=related

9/16/2010 11:38 am  #13


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Mags wrote:

one of my colleagues asked me who I would most want to be like if I could be any one that ever lived.  I told her, and meant it, "Pete Seeger" and perhaps still would.  Of course, being an ignorant person, she had never heard of him.  Several years ago, I got to meet him and had a rather lengthy conversation with him at the dedication of the Civil Rights museum here in Memphis.  I learned that Lee Hayes, the guy who does the initial monologue and is wheelchair bound, is the son of a Methodist minister from Arkansas.  I didn't ask what part.

Wow! Meeting Pete Seeger would be like . . . meeting John Lennon, except that he's dead, of course.  And actually having a convesation with him.  That's a life experience I would treasure.

Being him, . . . hmm, it sounds like a nice life:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pete_Seeger#Family_and_personal_life

9/16/2010 2:53 pm  #14


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Bruce Springsteen used to say that "This Land is Your Land" ought to be the national anthem.
You might be glad to know you're not alone in your affinity for Seeger, Mags. One of the summers I worked at a record warehouse, a lot of the Weavers catalog was released for the first time on CD (this was during the mid '80s, when record companies would release an artist's catalog on CD all at once, or like the Beatles parceled out with one LP per week) and the demand was pretty high. And it remained pretty consistent for a few weeks, unlike a lot of bands who would ship their stuff out all at once and the rush would last about 48 hours.
One of the other bands for which there was a similar phenomenon was the Psychadelic Furs. I never quite figured that one out.

9/16/2010 10:17 pm  #15


Re: Exclusionary Practices

artie_fufkin wrote:

You might be glad to know you're not alone in your affinity for Seeger, Mags.

I am very glad.  When I commented earlier on my colleague's ignorance, it was because she's only about 5 years younger than I.  I don't expect most people under 50 to know anything about him, though some do and the more fans he has the better the odds against his fading into oblivion.

He's got the same sort of appeal for me that Musial has.  I enjoy what he does but I enjoy what he is even more.

Actually, one of my best friends (one you and I have discussed in the context of ethnic humor and foibles) insists that I'm never happy unless I'm alone in my opinions.  But I think it is more a matter of her own perception of people in general and her experience with them.

I think I agree with Springsteen.

     Thread Starter

9/16/2010 10:21 pm  #16


Re: Exclusionary Practices

artie_fufkin wrote:

Bruce Springsteen used to say that "This Land is Your Land" ought to be the national anthem.

I grew up in a family where it kind of seemed like it was,

. . . not that it has much to do with Pete, since that was Woody's song.

9/16/2010 10:25 pm  #17


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Mags wrote:

the more fans he has the better the odds against his fading into oblivion.

Pete's huge, Mags.  I predict he'll be like Bob Marley, and become much bigger after we've lost him.  He stared down McCarthy and all the rest of 'em.  Even Pat Buchanon tried taking some cheap shots at him the night he was honored at . . . uh, Lincoln Center?  But he's bigger than all that.

Seriously, when are people going to stop singing, "If I Had a Hammer", or "Where Have All the Flowers Gone?"?  That's when Pete Seeger will fade away.

9/16/2010 11:04 pm  #18


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Max wrote:

artie_fufkin wrote:

Bruce Springsteen used to say that "This Land is Your Land" ought to be the national anthem.

I grew up in a family where it kind of seemed like it was,

. . . not that it has much to do with Pete, since that was Woody's song.

Actually, it has a lot to do with Pete.  Whenever someone does a special on Guthrie, they nearly always conclude with a group sing-a-long of this land is your land orchestrated by Pete.  Also, for many years, Pete performed and toured with Arlo Guthrie and they could be counted on to do the song.  In fact, many years before I got the chance to visit with Pete, my wife and I took friends to see a concert the two of them did in Memphis in the mid-eighties.  We went to dinner after it at my favorite Memphis restaurant, which means not a real pricey joint.  My wife and the wife with us got up to go to the women's room and ran into a friend of hers in the radio business who was having dinner with Arlo and got invited to sit down and visit with them.  I later told my wife that I wasn't nearly as jealous of them as I would have been if Pete had been at the table.

I think my second favorite Guthrie song is the one where he put his own lyrics to the traditional Wildwood Flower.  It's called "The Ruben James."  The Kingston Trio had a version of it in the early 60's, with Stewart I believe.

Last edited by Mags (9/17/2010 8:40 am)

     Thread Starter

9/17/2010 8:29 am  #19


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Max wrote:

artie_fufkin wrote:

Bruce Springsteen used to say that "This Land is Your Land" ought to be the national anthem.

I grew up in a family where it kind of seemed like it was,

. . . not that it has much to do with Pete, since that was Woody's song.

Forgive me, Max. I get Seeger and Guthrie confused sometimes.

9/17/2010 10:27 am  #20


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Mags wrote:

Actually, it has a lot to do with Pete.

Point conceded.  Pete was important not just for writing a few songs that will live on for many years, but because he popularized the songs of many others including Woody, Leadbelly, and others.  Most people know Goodnight Irene, if not from their parents singing it on car trips, then from The Weavers ot Pete Seeger, and few people have heard Leadbelly's version of it.  Ditto for "This Land is Your Land", although many other people have gone on to record that one, too, including Springsteen.

The Weavers did The Reuben James, too.  Sometimes I like the up-tempo songs, but . . .

My favorites tend to be ballads that are a bit melancholy.  I also feel that Albert Grossman's idea to dress up folk music a bit, with simpler, but more skillful arrangements, was a good idea, and I tend to find that Peter, Paul, and Mary make some of the most listenable versions of "folk music".  So of the things I put on mix tapes, er . . . iTunes playlists, and listen to a lot, it's "Tiny Sparrow" and "Old Coat", but for some reason, the only versions of those that i can find on YouTube are by that group from Minnesota who, for young kids, performed amazingly well.

9/18/2010 8:38 pm  #21


Re: Exclusionary Practices

Mags wrote:

How about starting a Music Thread II for people who want to discuss songs 40 and 50 years old and a Music Thread III for people who want to discuss songs 60 years old.

I remember a lot of these :









http://digitaldreamdoor.nutsie.com/pages/best_songs50s.html

9/18/2010 10:49 pm  #22


Re: Exclusionary Practices

don.rob11 wrote:

I remember a lot of these :

Thanks, Don.  I have to confess that I remember all but 4 and one of those four was by Elvis and one by Etta James.  At one time or another I had over half of them on 78 RPM's that my mother sold at a yard sale because I wasn't writing regularly when I was in the Navy.  Of course a lot of them were broken before I even went to college.  In Hot Springs, which was about 10 miles from where I lived up until '57, the was a record shop called Gill's Amusement that had the juke box concessions in many of the businesses in that area.  When they pulled records off the juke box, either because it was no longer getting places or because they were replacing the entire juke box with one they played 45's, they would put the 78's on a sale table at Gill's and sell them for 25 each or 6 for a dollar.  That's here I bought most of them.

I didn't study the cite enough yet to figure out how they arrived at the choices.  I would have thought that the Johnnie Burnette Trio (originally "The Rock and Roll Trio") version of "Honey Hush" was more popular than it's flip side, "The Train Kept a Rollin'. "  But I have their LP (33 & 1/3).

The Burnettes, Johnnie and Dorsey, and their lead guitar, Paul Burleson, were from Memphis, which I wasn't at the time.  They each had pretty big success with some solo releases but died young.  Their sons, Rocky and Billy, had some success a couple of decades ago and I think one of them sang with Fleetwood Mack during one of the periods when Lindsey Buckingham went out on his own.

Mom also unloaded my 45's, which included most of my Elvis not on LP.

     Thread Starter

9/19/2010 5:11 pm  #23


Re: Exclusionary Practices

78's , 33 1/3, 45, I remember an old handcrank phonograph my Grandmother once had .
All that old stuff brings to light about changes over the years , technology , etc. I still drive an old pick-up truck , and a few years back , when my youngest grandson first rode in it, he said "PawPaw what is this ?" Well he was referring to the manual handcrank that rolls the window up and down . I said , that makes the window go up and down . Well he began to push in on it like an automatic window . When he got no result, he said "PawPaw you crazy, you posed to push a button to make the window go up and down ! "

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum

Quotes = [quote][/quote] Bold = [b][/b] Underlined = [u][/u] Italic = [i][/i] Link = [url][/url] Code = [code][/code] Image = [img][/img] Video = [video][/video]