Offline
This is the first time I've written to you. Your predecessor had a drawer full of my letters, but until now I've not been concerned enough to contact you. I had something written down after the last three games of the NLCS last season, but I didn't end up sending it. Hey, it was your first year. You deserved a little bit of a pass.
So what's up? How's it going? Wait. Silly questions. We've all seen how it's going. Ever since you guys left St. Louis last Thursday, it's been sucky. We were all fat, dumb and happy after the Cardinals took two out of three from the Padres and swept the Phillies coming out of the All-Star break to go 25 games over .500. The playoffs were a lock. The division was practically a cinch. The Reds are too inconsistent. The Pirates can't hit for shit.
Then you got swept by the Braves. Hey, shit happens. They're a first place team, they were playing at home, their pitching is decent, the games were close, if a couple of calls go the other way, if a couple of hits drop in, blah blah blah. It was still OK. You were still in first because the Reds were getting clobbered out West and Pittsburgh lost two out of three to shitty Marlins. The Pirates' annual death walk had started. All you had to do was go to Pittsburgh this week and claim the body.
Then I don't know what the heck happened. Did you really have to start Westbrook on Monday? His testicles are the size of raisins anyway, but then you factor in he sucks on the road, and he's Pedro Alvarez's personal bitch. You had to know he was going to go out there and get lit up right away. The first inning of the first game was going to set the tone for the entire series, and you send out the baseball equivalent of the Tin Man. You had almost an entire week and then another off day a week ago Monday to set your rotation for this series. And you still sent Westbrook out there.
Then there was that double disaster on Tuesday. Game 1 never should have come to down to extra innings. You mean to tell me you can't get one lousy hit with RISP in nine at bats? Then you lost Yadi in Game 2, and the crap really hit the fan. Your guys looked dead. They wasted ABs. And you just stood there with a dumb look on your face like you were watching a movie in French without subtitles.
Then you threw away last night's game. Stopped playing once you got the lead. Hey, I know Marte was out at first, but bad calls are part of the game. Good teams use them for motivation. You went out there and asked questions of the umpire like you're Sgt. Joe Friday. It's OK to get pissed after he blows one. Throw your hat. Kick some dirt on him. Call him a cocksucker. You're not going to go to Hell.
While you're reading, here are a couple more ideas. How about starting a runner once in awhile? Ever heard of a hit-and-run? And can someone tell Kozma he's not a power pull hitter. Geez-us. He tries to yank anything closer than six inches off the plate. Same thing with Freese. Beltran needs to stop chopping at breaking pitches in the dirt. He looks like a gay lumberjack when he swings at that crap. Craig needs to lay off fastballs that are six inches inside. Get Carpenter to start hitting line drives again instead of trying to club everything out of the park. Do you guys even talk about this shit during batting practice?
Feel free to share these suggestions with your coaching staff. They don't seem to be doing much anyway. I still haven't figured out what Mike Aldrete's role is. And if Lilliquist doesn't take off that warmup jacket in 90-degree weather, you're going to have to peel it off him at the end of the season. You've got to do something before you get to Cincinnati. Those blood-thirsty rednecks are going to cook you and eat you if you keep playing this way.
Warm regards.
Your friend,
Artie
Last edited by artie_fufkin (8/01/2013 12:22 pm)
Offline
"You went out there and asked questions of the umpire like you're Anderson Cooper. It's OK to get pissed after he blows one. Throw your hat. Kick some dirt in him. Call him a cocksucker. You're not going to go to Hell. "
"And if Lilliquist doesn't take off that warmup jacket in 90-degree weather, you're going to have to peel it off him at the end of the season. "
two favorite parts.....epic post
Offline
I wish I could write like that , Artie , but just file me under dumb-ass....
Well done , well done
Offline
Gracias, both of you. AP, you'll notice I went back and changed Anderson Cooper to Sgt. Joe Friday. A little more arcane, perhaps, but I already had one gay reference to Beltran in there and I didn't want to run further afoul of the LBGT community.
Offline
It's posts like these that keep me coming to the board even though I won't watch another game until the Cardinals have won at least a couple. Watching isn't worth the frustration.
Offline
I agree with most of this, and I'm not the world's biggest Matheny fan, but I tend to think that his even-keel nature is the best form of leadership. Plus, I think the previous seven games were a perfect storm of all the Cardinals' weaknesses.
I *do* agree that he needed to get creative with his lineup and that he should've figured out a way around Westbrook, but that's not his style. There's no way in hell Matheny is going to tell Jake Westbrook that he doesn't get the ball in a crucial five-game series. Matheny is loyal to an extreme.
Offline
"There's no way in hell Matheny is going to tell Jake Westbrook that he doesn't get the ball in a crucial five-game series."
Of course Westbrook was going to pitch. I just question the wisdom of sending him out there in the first game of the series. He doesn't pitch well on the road, and he's especially bad at PNC, coming into the biggest game in Pittsburgh since Game 5 of the 1993 NLCS. The manager set his team up to fail, and the bottom of the first inning set the tone for the entire series.
One thing that was undervalued about La Russa was that he gave the ball to his best pitcher in big games. There's no way he would have had Wainwright make only one start in eight games against the Pirates and the Reds.
Offline
Oh I agree with you all the way; I'm just talking about Matheny's thinking.
Offline
I had the same feeling about leading with his chin...er, I mean, Westbrook. Jake was getting his ass handed to him in that early game that ended up postponed due to rain and this one was no different except that Mother Nature wasn't bailing him out. With most starters, you treat that as an anomaly and say "go get 'im today", but one's gut said differently. But with all that said, I agree with TK that it isn't MM's style to make that kind of judgment call. Hopefully the players appreciate that kind of vote of confidence enough to make up for what might be a less than optimal tactic.
Last edited by JV (8/01/2013 10:07 pm)
Offline
Speaking of votes of confidence, Artie... Nice work!
Offline
"Hopefully the players appreciate that kind of vote of confidence enough to make up for what might be a less than optimal tactic."
Understood. But then there's the argument that these guys are professionals. If Westbrook's feelings are hurt by the rotation being jiggered so he doesn't start in the first game of a series against a team he doesn't pitch well against in a park where he doesn't pitch well with first place on the line, then that's mostly Westbrook's problem, not Matheny's.
Offline
artie_fufkin wrote:
"Hopefully the players appreciate that kind of vote of confidence enough to make up for what might be a less than optimal tactic."
Understood. But then there's the argument that these guys are professionals. If Westbrook's feelings are hurt by the rotation being jiggered so he doesn't start in the first game of a series against a team he doesn't pitch well against in a park where he doesn't pitch well with first place on the line, then that's mostly Westbrook's problem, not Matheny's.
True, but it wasn't Westbrook's feelings I was talking about. I was proposing a pie-in-the-sky scenario in which the team as a whole values expressions of loyalty more than tough managerial decisions. I suspect that's probably unlikely and that I've veered off into Maxville.
Last edited by JV (8/02/2013 3:31 pm)