Offline
NL MVP
Molina
Goldschmidt
McCutcheon
NL CY Young
Kershaw
Fernandez
Wainwright
NL ROY
Fernandez
Miller
Puig
NL Manager of the Year
Mattingly
Hurdle
Gonzalez
AL MVP
Cabrera
Trout
Davis
AL Cy Young
Scherzer
Darvish
Iwakuma
AL ROY
Archer
Myers
Iglesias
AL Manager
Farrell
Francona
Melvin
Offline
forsberg_us wrote:
NL MVP
Molina
Goldschmidt
McCutcheon - As much as I like Yadi, McCutheon deserves this for leading the Pirates to the playoffs for the first time since forever.
NL CY Young
Kershaw - If this isn't at least nearly unanimous, there's something wrong
Fernandez
Wainwright
NL ROY
Fernandez - You could make an argument the Dodgers got good only after Puig arrived, but Fernadez was solid for an entire season, not just 2/3rds of it.
Miller
Puig
NL Manager of the Year
Mattingly
Hurdle - See comment about McCutcheon
Gonzalez
AL MVP
Cabrera - I know he sucked in the playoffs, but this is a regular season award and Cabrera's offensive numbers in the regular season were enough (again) to overcome an almost complete lack of defense
Trout
Davis
AL Cy Young
Scherzer - So far out in front of everyone else in this category it reminds me of Secretariat in the Belmont Stakes
Darvish
Iwakuma
AL ROY
Archer
Myers - Flip a three-headed coin, I suppose. Best of a weak field.
Iglesias
AL Manager
Farrell - Again, playoffs aren't taken into consideration, but Farrell wins anyway for taking a last place team to the top of the division. Makes you realize how much of a dunderhead boob Bobby Valentine is.
Francona
Melvin
Offline
Artie i disagree on molina. If u hit that well and play the position of catcher u should be mvp every year. I dont see what the pirates making the playoffs has to do with mvp when the other guy made it to the ws. The rest of ur pick i agree with.